John Stith Pemberton—pharmacist, Civil War veteran, inventor of the original Coca-Cola syrup in 1886—left behind formulas, business records, and a complicated legacy. But nowhere in the historical record does he mention a favorite color.
Personal preferences like favorite colors rarely survive for 19th-century figures unless recorded in letters, diaries, or contemporary accounts. Pemberton's surviving papers focus on his pharmaceutical work, his morphine addiction (from a war wound), and his business dealings. Not aesthetics.
So if you're designing a Pemberton-themed trivia night, a historical novel, or a very specific cocktail napkin: you're free to invent. He never said otherwise.