A single "reasonable price" for the five Exodia pieces cannot be given without specifics. Value depends heavily on:
To estimate: Check completed listings on eBay, TCGplayer, and Troll and Toad filtering by condition and rarity; consult price guides like Beckett or PriceCharting; ask local game stores for regional trends. Remember, price is subjective—factor in your needs and the cards' state before buying or selling.