Shakespeare wrote Romeo and Juliet c. 1591–1595 (first performed ~1597) during his early London career. Multiple motives converged:
Primary source: Arthur Brooke's The Tragical History of Romeus and Juliet (1562), a 3,000-line poem translating Bandello's Italian novella (1554). Shakespeare compressed Brooke's 9 months into 5 days, aged Juliet from 16 to 13, invented Mercutio and the Nurse's humor, and transformed moralistic verse into dramatic poetry.
Elizabethan audiences loved Italian settings, forbidden love, and blood feuds. Titus Andronicus (1594) proved violence sold; A Midsummer Night's Dream (1595) proved lyricism sold. Romeo and Juliet combined both.
Shakespeare used the play to master: sonnet form (prologue, shared sonnet at 1.5), rhymed couplets for ritual moments, blank verse flexibility, and the comedy-to-tragedy pivot (Act 3.1). It's a technical showcase.
The Prince's closing verdict—"All are punished"—implicates the entire civic order. The play asks: what social structures make love fatal?
Shakespeare didn't "choose" the story—he inherited it. His genius was what he did with it: accelerated time, deepened psychology, and made a local Italian legend universal.