The witches don't tell Macbeth how to become king. They tell him that he will. That gap—between prophecy and method—is where tragedy lives.
Status: Fulfilled externally. The current Thane is executed for treason; Duncan rewards Macbeth's battlefield valor with the title. No action required. This validation hooks Macbeth—it proves the witches' pipeline to truth.
Status: Self-fulfilling through violence. The prophecy doesn't say "murder Duncan." But Macbeth's ambition fills the silence. He and Lady Macbeth choose the "how." The prophecy is a mirror reflecting his latent desire—and he mistakes reflection for command.
Status: Technically true, strategically fatal. Macduff was "from his mother's womb / Untimely ripped"—Caesarean section. The prophecy exploits a semantic loophole in "born." Macbeth reads it as invincibility; it's actually a trap door.
Each prophecy is literally true but strategically incomplete. The witches deal in equivocation—truth shaped to mislead. They don't force Macbeth's hand. They just show him a door, knowing he'll kick it down.
If the witches commanded, Macbeth would be a puppet. Because they predict, he's an agent. His choices—murder, tyranny, denial—are his. The prophecies are the occasion, not the cause.
Macbeth builds his own hell on the foundation of their words.