* Randolph Scott as Judge Roy Bean
* Virginia Mayo as Maria Elena Xaviera Delgado
* Karen Steele as Lil Daggett
* Brian Donlevy as Marshal Seth Doane
* Wallace Ford as Preacher
* Michael Pate as Pancho
* Andrew Duggan as "Bulldog" Burnett
* John Carradine as "Yellow Rose"
* Lee Van Cleef as Dutch Henry Brown
* Raymond Hatton as "Pop" Dawson