The witches' chant—"Fair is foul, and foul is fair" (1.1.12)—establishes the play's moral instability. Shakespeare develops this through five interconnected strategies:
Macbeth: loyal thane → regicide → tyrant. Lady Macbeth: "unsex me here" resolve → sleepwalking guilt. Neither purely good nor evil; both contain opposing impulses.
Lady Macbeth adopts "masculine" agency (ambition, violence-planning); Macbeth displays "feminine" vulnerability (hallucinations, fear). The play destabilizes rigid gender-coded virtues/vices.
Witches' prophecies ("none of woman born," "Birnam Wood") are technically true but deceptively framed. Language itself becomes unreliable—meaning slips between intention and outcome.
Day = legitimacy, clarity, goodness (Duncan's reign). Night = murder, concealment, corruption (Macbeth's reign). Yet "light thickens" as evil advances; the binary collapses.
Prophecies seem fated, but Macbeth chooses each murder. The weird sisters catalyze; they don't compel. Agency and destiny blur—opposites co-creating tragedy.
This pervasive duality prevents moral complacency. Audiences cannot comfortably categorize characters; the play insists that good and evil are not external forces but internal capacities within every human.