The most famous shocking audition in UK talent show history is Susan Boyle on Britain's Got Talent (2009), not The X Factor. Her performance of "I Dreamed a Dream" stunned judges and audience, going viral globally (over 100M YouTube views). She finished 2nd and became a global star.
On The X Factor UK itself, notable shocking auditions include:
If the question strictly means X Factor UK, there's no single consensus "most shocking," but Boyle's BGT audition is the cultural touchstone.