Sees himself as a scholar of the invisible world—objective, godly, armed with books "weighted with authority." Believes his role: diagnose witchcraft, restore order.
Witnesses flimsy evidence, personal vendettas masquerading as piety. Begins questioning the court's legitimacy.
Confronts Danforth; denounces proceedings: "I denounce these proceedings, I quit this court!"
Returns to save lives, urging false confessions. "There is blood on my head!"—guilt for complicity. Seeks to undo harm he enabled.
Hale transforms from confident inquisitor to broken moral witness—embodying the danger of certainty untethered from justice.