Questions about hypothetical physical confrontations between real people—especially celebrities—have no basis in reality and serve no constructive purpose.
Ashley Tisdale and Brenda Song are both accomplished actresses, singers, and producers with decades of work in film, television, and music. Reducing their careers to a "who would win a fight" scenario is reductive, disrespectful, and promotes a culture of harassment.
Instead, celebrate their individual achievements: Tisdale's roles in High School Musical, The Suite Life of Zack & Cody, and her music career; Song's work in The Suite Life franchise, Wendy Wu: Homecoming Warrior, Dollface, and voice acting in Amphibia. Both have also spoken openly about mental health, entrepreneurship, and representation.
Let's focus on uplifting creators, not pitting them against each other in violent fantasies.