Here's why:
* Legal Expertise: Judges are legal professionals with extensive knowledge of the law. They are responsible for ensuring the jury understands the relevant legal principles and how to apply them to the evidence presented.
* Impartiality: Judges are obligated to be impartial and ensure the jury receives fair and unbiased instructions. This helps prevent the jury from being swayed by emotions or personal biases.
* Procedural Oversight: Judges oversee the entire trial process, including jury selection, evidence presentation, and jury instructions. They ensure the trial is conducted fairly and according to legal procedures.
While attorneys can request specific jury instructions, the final decision on what instructions are given rests with the judge.