Arts >> Theater >> Stage Acting

Was Al Pacino the First Choice for Michael Corleone?

No. The studio (Paramount) and producer Robert Evans initially wanted a bankable star. Their preference order:

  1. Robert Redford — Declined (felt wrong for the role).
  2. Martin Sheen — Screen-tested; considered too slight.
  3. Warren Beatty — Wanted to direct; passed on acting.
  4. Jack Nicholson — Declined ("It's an Italian part; play an Italian").
  5. Ryan O'Neal — Screen-tested; rejected.
  6. James Caan — Wanted Michael; cast as Sonny instead.

Francis Ford Coppola championed the unknown Al Pacino after seeing his Off-Broadway work (The Indian Wants the Bronx). The studio resisted—calling him "too short," "not a star," "looks like a waiter." Coppola threatened to walk. Pacino's screen test (the restaurant scene) was electrifying—quiet menace, coiled violence. He won the role.

Pacino's salary: $35,000 (vs. Brando's $50k + points). The rest is cinema history.

Stage Acting

Related Categories