Arts >> Theater >> Plays

Josh Herdman Steps In: The Recasting of Vincent Crabbe

When Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince began production, a familiar Slytherin face was missing. Jamie Waylett, who had played Vincent Crabbe since the first film, was gone—replaced by Josh Herdman for the final two installments.

Why the Change?

Waylett's 2009 arrest for cannabis possession led to his departure from the franchise. The production, already deep into the series' darker second half, needed a quick but seamless transition. Herdman, who had actually played Gregory Goyle in earlier films (alongside Waylett's Crabbe), slid into the role with minimal disruption.

A Subtle Shift

Herdman's Crabbe is quieter, heavier—less the bumbling sidekick, more a looming presence. The change reflects the story's maturation: the goons of childhood become genuine threats in a war. Herdman carries that weight without mimicry, making the recasting feel like character evolution rather than replacement.

Waylett's legal troubles later escalated (he served prison time for his role in the 2011 London riots), cementing the decision as necessary. Herdman, meanwhile, continued acting post-Potter, notably in the thriller Panic and the series Marcella.

In a franchise defined by consistency, this was a rare crack—but one handled with professionalism that preserved the story's integrity.

Plays

Related Categories