In Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest, Jack Sparrow leaves two marks on Cutler Beckett:
During their confrontation aboard the Flying Dutchman, Jack cuts Beckett's left cheek with his sword—a visible scar Beckett bears in At World's End.
The deeper mark is Beckett's consuming fixation on capturing/killing Jack. Jack's escape, mockery, and theft of the compass (which points to one's heart's desire) unravel Beckett's controlled, transactional worldview. Beckett abandons strategy for vendetta, leading to his death in the maelstrom.
As Jack says: "You know that feeling you get when you're being watched? That's me." The scar is superficial; the obsession is fatal.