* Different actors, different styles: Redford and DiCaprio are both masterful actors, but their strengths lie in different areas. Redford is known for his stoic presence and quiet intensity, while DiCaprio is known for his emotional depth and intensity.
* Different roles, different eras: Both actors have played a wide range of roles across their careers. It's unfair to compare them based on a single role, especially if the roles are vastly different.
* Subjective opinion: Ultimately, who plays a role better is a matter of personal preference. What one person finds compelling, another may not.
To make a more meaningful comparison, you would need to specify:
* Which specific roles are you comparing? For example, are you comparing Redford's performance in "The Sting" to DiCaprio's in "Inception"?
* What criteria are you using to define "better"? Are you looking for technical skill, emotional impact, or something else entirely?
Once you have a more specific comparison, you can start to analyze the performances and form your own opinion. However, remember that both Redford and DiCaprio are incredibly talented actors with distinct strengths, and there's no right or wrong answer.