How Did Amundsen Beat Scott to the South Pole?
Roald Amundsen reached the South Pole December 14, 1911; Robert Falcon Scott arrived January 17, 1912 (33 days later). Amundsen's victory came from superior strategy, preparation, and adaptation:
1. Transportation: Dogs vs. Ponies / Motors / Man-Hauling
- Amundsen: 52 Greenland dogs — evolved for polar travel, eat seal/penguin meat (local fuel), pull 2x weight, provide warmth. Expert handlers (Norwegian ski culture).
- Scott: 19 Siberian ponies (sweat → ice on coat → freeze; need imported fodder; sank in soft snow), 3 motor sledges (engine failure in cold), then man-hauling (exhausting, slow).
2. Route: Axel Heiberg Glacier vs. Beardmore Glacier
- Amundsen: Discovered new route — shorter (60 mi less), steeper but firmer snow, less crevassed. Axial glacier to Polar Plateau.
- Scott: Beardmore Glacier — longer, heavily crevassed, chaotic icefalls. Known route (Shackleton 1908).
3. Depots & Supplies
- Amundsen: Pre-laid depots (Feb 1911) every degree (82°S–88°S). 3 tons supplies for 5 men. Seal meat/pemmican (high fat, vit C — prevented scurvy). Black tents (absorb sun).
- Scott: Depots laid later, less food. One Ton Depot placed 30 mi short of plan (ponies failed). Rations marginal; no fresh meat → scurvy.
4. Clothing & Gear
- Amundsen: Inuit-style fur suits (caribou, sealskin) — breathable, windproof, lightweight. Learned from Netsilik Inuit (Gjøa Haven, 1903–06).
- Scott: Wool / gabardine / windproof cotton — absorbed sweat, froze, heavy, less insulation.
5. Skiing Proficiency
- Amundsen: Expert skiers (national sport). Glided effortlessly.
- Scott: Novices — walked/skied poorly. Man-hauling on foot.
6. Leadership & Focus
- Amundsen: Single goal: Pole. No science. Turned back at 88°23'S (depot) to ensure survival. "Victory awaits him who has everything in order."
- Scott: Dual goal: Pole + Science (geology, fossils — 35 lbs rocks hauled to death). Refused dogs on plateau ("unsporting").
Outcome
Amundsen's team returned safely (Jan 25, 1912). Scott's polar party (Scott, Wilson, Bowers, Oates, Evans) perished on return (Mar 1912) — starvation, scurvy, blizzard, 11 mi from One Ton Depot.