Comparing The Exorcist (1973) and Play (1972, directed by Anthony Page, from Samuel Beckett's one-act) is like comparing a sledgehammer to a scalpel. Both cut. Differently.
Strengths: Groundbreaking practical effects (head rotation, levitation, projectile vomiting), realistic exorcism ritual, deep psychological trauma for mother/daughter/priests. The horror is externalized—a demon invading a body.
Weaknesses: Some effects date; shock reliance can feel repetitive to desensitized modern viewers.
Strengths: Three heads in urns (post-mortem), interrogated by a spotlight. No gore, no jumps. Pure existential horror—memory, guilt, infidelity, the inescapable past. Beckett's sparse, rhythmic text. Atmosphere over spectacle.
Weaknesses: Extreme minimalism tests patience. No traditional narrative. Horror is intellectual, not visceral.
The Exorcist terrifies through loss of bodily control. Your body betrays you; something else drives.
Play unsettles through the inescapability of memory. You are your past; you cannot leave the urn.
The "scarier" film depends entirely on which fear lives deeper in you.