* Kenny Wormald as Ren McCormack
* Julianne Hough as Ariel Moore
* Dennis Quaid as Reverend Shaw Moore
* Andie MacDowell as Vi Moore
* Miles Teller as Willard Hewitt
* Ziah Colon as Rusty Rodriguez
* Ray McKinnon as Wes Warnicker
* Kim Dickens as Lulu Warnicker
* Patrick John Flueger as Chuck Cranston
* Sydney Saylor as Sarah Warnicker
* Serayah McNeill as Wendy Jo
* Briana Evigan as Ashley
* Katie Stevens as Mona Lisa
* Donna Murphy as Ethel McCormack