Epic theatre (Bertolt Brecht) and naturalism (Henrik Ibsen, Konstantin Stanislavski) represent opposing theatrical philosophies:
| Aspect | Epic Theatre | Naturalism |
|---|---|---|
| Goal | Didactic: provoke critical analysis of social issues | Illusion of reality: immerse audience in believable life |
| Audience Relation | Alienation Effect (Verfremdungseffekt): prevent emotional identification | Fourth Wall maintained: audience as unseen observers |
| Acting Style | Actors as storytellers; demonstrate character, don’t fully become it | Actors embody character psychologically (Stanislavski system) |
| Structure | Non-linear: fragments, flashbacks, songs, direct address | Linear, chronological cause-and-effect narrative |
| Staging | Minimalist: visible lighting, placards, sparse props | Detailed, realistic sets replicating actual environments |
| Narrative Voice | Often includes a narrator/commentator | No narrator; story unfolds through action/dialogue |
| Key Figures | Bertolt Brecht, Erwin Piscator | Henrik Ibsen, Konstantin Stanislavski, André Antoine |
In essence, epic theatre asks “Why?” and demands judgment; naturalism asks “How?” and demands empathy.