There was never a single play titled "Back to Methuselah" performed in theatres. The title belongs to George Bernard Shaw's five-play cycle, published in 1921, spanning from 4004 BC to 31,920 AD.
The cycle comprises:
Individual plays from the cycle have been staged over the decades, but "Back to Methuselah" refers to the published collection—a metaphysical epic, not a theatrical evening.