Asking for "Rosie's favorite NYC restaurant" is like asking for "the best book" without specifying genre, era, or reader. The answer depends entirely on which Rosie you mean.
New York City has over 25,000 restaurants. Without knowing Rosie's identity—not to mention her mood, occasion, and company—any recommendation would be a shot in the dark.
Provide context. Tell us who Rosie is, and we'll narrow it down.