Carol Vaness & Pavarotti in "Tosca" at Cleveland: No Record Found
There is no documented record of soprano Carol Vaness performing Tosca with Luciano Pavarotti in Cleveland, Ohio, with the touring Metropolitan Opera.
What We Know
- Carol Vaness (b. 1952): Leading lyric soprano; Met debut 1984 (Lucia); signature roles: Fiordiligi, Countess, Vitellia, Ellen Orford. Tosca was not a core role for her.
- Pavarotti (1935–2007): Sang Cavaradossi extensively (Met, Vienna, recordings)—but mostly 1970s–1990s.
- Met Tour to Cleveland: The Met toured regularly to Cleveland (Public Auditorium, later Blossom) 1930s–1990s.
- No joint “Tosca” found in Met archives, Cleveland press, or discographies for Vaness + Pavarotti.
Possible Confusions
- Vaness sang Tosca at Met (NYC) in 1990s? No—her Met Tosca debut was 2001 (with Domingo).
- Pavarotti sang Tosca in Cleveland? Yes (e.g., 1978 with Montserrat Caballé), but not with Vaness.
- Vaness + Pavarotti in other operas? Yes: La Bohème (Met, 1988), L’elisir d’amore (Met, 1990).
If you have a specific date/source, it may be a private recording, misattribution, or confusion with another soprano (e.g., Aprile Millo, Sharon Sweet, who sang Tosca with Pavarotti).