Critiquing The Phantom of the Opera's Scenery: Opulence, Overload, and Cost
Critics argue:
- Over-the-top opulence: Massive, moving sets (e.g., the subterranean lair) can distract from the story and characters.
- Visual overload: Excessive detail and mechanics (the chandelier, the boat, the rotating sets) may overwhelm rather than enhance.
- Cost: Original Broadway production cost >$10M (sets >$1M), making it prohibitively expensive for many regional theaters.
- Style over substance: Spectacle sometimes substitutes for emotional depth.
Defenders cite the spectacle as integral to the gothic romance atmosphere and a major draw for audiences.