Despite centuries of speculation, no definitive record exists identifying a personal favorite among Shakespeare's plays. He left no letters, diary entries, or recorded conversations naming a preferred work.
Scholars and admirers have their favorites—Hamlet for philosophical depth, King Lear for tragic grandeur, The Tempest for autobiographical resonance—but these are projections, not evidence. Shakespeare the writer was a craftsman producing for a company, an audience, and a living; his "favorite" may have simply been the one that paid the bills or pleased the patron.
The silence is fitting: the man who gave us infinite perspectives never fixed his own.