1. Brutus' Speech:
- Initial Support: Initially, Brutus' speech is met with support from the plebeians. They are swayed by his logical reasoning, appeal to their sense of justice, and his portrayal of Caesar's ambition. Brutus emphasizes that he acted for the greater good of Rome and the preservation of their freedom.
- Shifting Sentiment: However, as Brutus' speech progresses, some plebeians begin to question his arguments. They are influenced by his lack of emotional appeal, his failure to address Caesar's positive achievements, and his rigid adherence to abstract ideals.
2. Antony's Speech:
- Emotional Impact: Antony's speech is characterized by its powerful emotional appeal. He skillfully uses rhetorical devices, gestures, and visual aids to stir up the emotions of the plebeians. By displaying Caesar's bloodied cloak and appealing to their personal connection with Caesar, Antony evokes a sense of pity, anger, and resentment.
- Heightened Hostility: Antony effectively exploits the plebeians' sympathies to turn them against Brutus and the conspirators. His speech succeeds in inciting a riotous reaction from the crowd, leading them to demand vengeance for Caesar's death.
In essence, Brutus' speech elicits initial support based on logical reasoning, but it lacks emotional connection. Antony's speech, on the other hand, taps into the plebeians' emotions, igniting their anger and resentment, which dramatically shifts their attitude toward the conspirators.