The rhetorical device that presents only two alternatives when a spectrum of options exists is called a false dichotomy (also known as a false dilemma).
It works by oversimplifying a complex issue, forcing the audience into a binary choice between two extremes—often "all or nothing," "with us or against us," or "option A or disaster." This ignores middle ground, nuanced positions, or entirely different solutions.
Example: "Either we cut all social programs, or the economy will collapse." (Ignores targeted reforms, revenue increases, phased adjustments, etc.)
Recognizing false dichotomies is essential for critical thinking—they're common in political rhetoric, advertising, and everyday arguments. The antidote: ask, "What other options exist?"