Hohenheim vs. Father in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood – Not the Same Person
The relationship is not a simple "yes/no." Here's the precise breakdown:
- Van Hohenheim = Biological father of Edward & Alphonse Elric. Human, immortal (Philosopher's Stone core), ~400 years old.
- "Father" (Homunculus) = Artificial being created from Hohenheim's blood in Xerxes. Originally the "Dwarf in the Flask" (Homunculus).
- Origin: Father tricked the King of Xerxes into a nationwide transmutation circle, sacrificing the population to give both himself and Hohenheim immortal bodies (Philosopher's Stones). Hohenheim received half the souls; Father the other half.
- Separation: They are two distinct entities from that moment. Father purged his seven sins to create the Homunculi (Lust, Gluttony, etc.); Hohenheim wandered, atoning.
Conclusion: Hohenheim is the biological father of the Elric brothers. Father is their genetic progenitor via Hohenheim's blood but a separate consciousness—and the series' ultimate antagonist. They share a soul-source but are not the same person.