Incident Commander & After-Action Review Leadership: No Universal "Chief"
There is no universal "correct chief" for incident management and after-action reviews (AAR). The appropriate leader depends entirely on organizational structure and incident type.
Key Determining Factors
- Incident Type: Emergencies use a designated Incident Commander (IC) (NIMS/ICS standard). Business/IT incidents may use a Crisis Manager, Service Owner, or Major Incident Manager.
- Organizational Hierarchy: Hierarchical orgs follow chain of command; flat orgs may assign based on expertise.
- Defined Roles: Best practice: pre-assign Incident Manager (response) and AAR Facilitator (review) in policy. They can be the same person or different.
Essential Qualities for the Role
- Authority to decide and allocate resources.
- Technical/Operational Expertise relevant to the incident.
- Communication Skills for coordination and stakeholder updates.
- Objectivity for the AAR to identify root causes without blame.
Bottom line: Define roles in your incident response plan beforehand. Ad-hoc decisions during crises cause confusion and accountability gaps.