The irony is biographical and structural:
Before the trials, Cheever was himself accused of witchcraft by Abigail’s circle. He was imprisoned, interrogated, and survived—likely by confessing or accusing others.
Now, as court clerk/constable, he arrests Elizabeth Proctor on Abigail’s poppet “evidence.” He enforces the very mechanism that victimized him.
Cheever is a minor character embodying the play’s central tragedy: institutional evil consumes individual conscience.