Analyzing “He Comes Like a Catastrophe of Old Comedy” in King Lear: Metatheatrical Irony
The phrase “he comes like a catastrophe of old comedy” (from King Lear, Act 4, Scene 6, spoken by Edgar describing his father Gloucester) uses metatheatrical imagery.
Meaning:
- Catastrophe: In classical comedy, the “catastrophe” is the final resolution/denouement—often a recognition scene where identities are revealed and order restored.
- Old Comedy: Refers to Aristophanic Greek comedy, with chaotic, fantastical resolutions.
- Application: Gloucester’s entrance—blind, suffering, led by a madman (Edgar disguised as Poor Tom)—parodies a comic resolution. Instead of joyful reunion, it’s a grotesque, tragic “recognition.”
Effect: The metaphor underscores the play’s inversion of comic conventions: where comedy ends in marriage/harmony, Lear ends in blindness, madness, and death. It highlights the grotesque absurdity of human suffering.