"Tragedy in Itself" vs. "Tragedy of Itself": A Subtle Distinction
The phrases are nearly synonymous, but the preposition shifts the focus.
- "Tragedy in itself" — Emphasizes inherent quality. The thing contains tragedy as an essential property. The consequences are already evident or inevitable. Example: "The loss of the library was a tragedy in itself, quite apart from the historical data destroyed."
- "Tragedy of itself" — Emphasizes self-contained misfortune. The event is unfortunate by its very nature, without reference to external effects. Example: "The tragedy of itself was that he never knew how loved he was."
In practice, writers often use them interchangeably. The distinction matters only in precise philosophical or literary analysis where "in" points to internal constitution and "of" points to self-referential essence.