1. Motive: The kidnappers in Winnie's imagination were driven by greed or other selfish desires. They abduct people for ransom, monetary gain, or personal advantage. On the other hand, the Tucks were portrayed as compassionate individuals who kidnapped Winnie out of concern for her safety. They recognized that Winnie might reveal their secret of everlasting life to the outside world, putting them at risk. While still a form of kidnapping, their intention was protective rather than malicious.
2. Treatment: Winnie imagined kidnappers to be cruel, violent, and ruthless. She feared they would harm or even kill her if they discovered her knowledge of their secret. In contrast, the Tucks treated Winnie with kindness and respect throughout her time with them. They provided her with a safe haven, food, and shelter. The Tuck's intention was not to cause her any harm, but to keep her away from danger.
3. Interaction: In Winnie's imagination, kidnappers are typically portrayed as cold and distant. They have little to no emotional connection with their victims and view them as mere objects. The Tucks, however, engaged with Winnie on a personal level. They shared their stories, thoughts, and feelings with her. They developed a bond with Winnie, treating her as a friend and even like family.
4. Long-term Goal: Winnie's perception of kidnappers aligned more with a conventional understanding of their objectives. She believed that kidnappers would ultimately demand ransom or keep her captive for some nefarious purpose. The Tucks, on the other hand, had a unique intention behind their actions. They wanted to protect their secret and ensure that Winnie did not inadvertently put herself or others at risk by revealing it.
In summary, while both kidnappers and the Tucks engage in taking an individual against their will, their motivations, treatment of the person involved, and long-term goals are distinct. Winnie's idea of kidnappers represented the stereotypical portrayal of individuals driven by greed and ruthlessness, while the Tucks, despite their unconventional actions, acted out of care and the desire to preserve their secret.