Specifically, Proctor seeks to use his own good reputation to persuade the court of Elizabeth's innocence, claiming that she would not be capable of the kind of malice that Abigail accuses her of. Here are some key points Proctor makes about Elizabeth in the play:
- He Praises Her Religiosity: Despite the conflict she has with Abigail, John insists that Elizabeth is a faithful and dedicated Christian who adheres strictly to the religious principles and practices of their Puritan community.
- He Claims She Is Not Superstitious: Proctor emphasizes that Elizabeth lacks any interest in superstitions and witchcraft, contrasting her with Abigail and the other girls accusing her. He asserts that Elizabeth is a practical woman who does not believe in supernatural forces.
- He Points to Her Moral Character: John states that Elizabeth is inherently moral and would never willingly engage in any immoral or corrupt behavior. He implies that witchcraft is immoral and argues that Elizabeth's nature would prevent her from participating in it.
- He Affirms Her Honesty: John vouches for Elizabeth's honesty and trustworthiness. He tells the court that Elizabeth has always been truthful to him and others, casting doubt on Abigail's accusations and suggesting that Abigail might be lying.