Was Society Responsible for the Monster's Actions in Frankenstein? A Shared Responsibility Analysis
Yes, to a significant extent. Mary Shelley's Frankenstein presents a shared responsibility between creator (Victor) and society.
Victor's Responsibility (Primary)
- Created life without preparation for its needs.
- Abandoned it immediately — no guidance, love, education.
- Refused to create a mate after promising, dooming it to solitude.
Society's Responsibility (Critical)
- Universal rejection based solely on appearance — villagers, William, De Laceys, strangers.
- No due process — judged guilty by face alone.
- Denied basic humanity — no chance to integrate, work, belong.
- Fear → violence cycle: Monster's violence follows rejection; it's reactive, not innate.
The Creature's Own Words
"I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend. Make me happy, and I shall again be virtuous." (Ch. 17)
Conclusion
Victor created the potential; society actualized the monster through relentless ostracism. Shelley critiques both scientific hubris and social prejudice. The creature is made, not born.