Scar:
* Motive: Power and revenge. Scar is driven by a deep-seated resentment for his brother Mufasa, wanting to usurp the throne. He is manipulative and cunning, using fear and deception to achieve his goals.
* Methods: He orchestrates the death of Mufasa and blames it on Simba, leading to Simba's exile. He then establishes himself as a tyrannical ruler, imposing his will on the Pride Lands and causing widespread suffering.
* Cruelty: Scar is ruthless and enjoys inflicting pain on others. He is responsible for the death of many lions and the destruction of the Pride Lands.
Captain Hook:
* Motive: Fear and obsession. Captain Hook is consumed by his fear of Peter Pan, a fear stemming from Peter's having cut off Hook's hand and fed it to a crocodile. He seeks revenge and tries to eliminate Peter Pan at all costs.
* Methods: He is a cunning and resourceful pirate, using trickery and violence to achieve his goals. He is constantly scheming and plotting against Peter Pan and his friends.
* Cruelty: Hook is generally less overtly cruel than Scar. His primary evil stems from his paranoia and obsession with Peter Pan, which leads him to engage in ruthless acts and endanger the lives of others.
Conclusion:
* Scar is arguably more directly responsible for widespread death and destruction. He orchestrates the murder of his brother and leads the Pride Lands into a period of chaos.
* Captain Hook is more driven by his fear and paranoia. He is obsessed with Peter Pan, but his evil is less directly impactful on a large scale.
Ultimately, the "more evil" character depends on your interpretation of their motives and actions. Both Scar and Captain Hook are classic villains with their own distinct forms of evil.