Bard the Bowman vs. The Master of Lake-town: Who Really Killed Smaug?
There's a common misconception about the defense of Lake-town (Esgaroth) in The Hobbit. Let's set the record straight: The Master of Lake-town was a cowardly politician who fled; Bard the Bowman was the hero who killed Smaug.
The Master's "Defense"
- Fled in his gilded boat, loaded with gold, while the town burned.
- Survived the initial attack but later died of starvation in the Waste (book) or was killed in the Battle of Five Armies (film).
- Took no heroic action whatsoever.
Bard's Heroism
- Organized the town's defense, ordering archers to hold the line.
- Received the thrush's message revealing Smaug's bare patch (information from Bilbo).
- Fired his ancestral Black Arrow into the hollow by Smaug's left breast.
- Smaug crashed onto Esgaroth, destroying the town.
- Led the survivors to rebuild Dale and was crowned King.
Key Distinction
Master = Politician; Bard = Hero. Both the book (Chapter 14) and the films differentiate them clearly. Bard's lineage as a descendant of Girion of Dale and his skill with a bow made him the true leader the people needed.