Johnny Depp's Mad Hatter in Alice in Wonderland (2010) defies simple moral categorization—but the film positions him sympathetically as a traumatized survivor, not an agent of evil.
The Hatter's "madness" stems from witnessing his family's destruction and enduring the Red Queen's tyranny. His erratic behavior functions as a coping mechanism for unprocessed trauma, not inherent malice.
He risks everything to aid Alice's quest to overthrow the Red Queen—guiding her, fighting for her, and ultimately joining the rebellion. His actions consistently serve liberation, not oppression.
Moments like the violent "Futterwacken" rage read as dissociative episodes triggered by overwhelming emotion, not calculated cruelty. The film frames these as symptoms, not choices.
Burton's Wonderland is a dictatorship; the Hatter is a resistance fighter broken by loss. While his unpredictability unsettles, the narrative aligns him with the oppressed. Interpretation varies, but the film's weight falls on tragedy, not villainy.