Thorin’s Evolving Relationships with Bard and the Elvenking in The Hobbit
Thorin Oakenshield’s interactions with Bard the Bowman and Thranduil, the Elvenking, shift from outright hostility to grudging respect and cooperation.
Initial Conflict
- Bard: Thorin accuses him of stealing the Arkenstone and refuses to aid Dale’s reconstruction, viewing Men as inferior.
- Thranduil: Ancient grievances over the Dwarves’ exile fuel Thorin’s refusal to share the treasure.
Shifting Dynamics
- Bard: After the Battle of Five Armies, Thorin acknowledges Bard’s courage and leadership.
- Thranduil: The Elvenking shows compassion, negotiates, and joins forces against Smaug.
Resolution
- Thorin concedes Bard’s claim for damages caused by Smaug and agrees to share the hoard.
- Thranduil allies with Dwarves against the Orcs, hinting at a fragile but possible future peace.
Thorin’s arc teaches that reclaiming a mountain is hollow without the wisdom to share its bounty.