Alastor Moody in Goblet of Fire: Good or Bad?
The character appearing as "Moody" in Goblet of Fire is Barty Crouch Jr. impersonating the real Alastor Moody via Polyjuice Potion. The real Moody—a legendary Auror—is imprisoned in a magical trunk for the entire book.
Real Moody (Good):
- Elite Dark Wizard catcher; fought Voldemort directly.
- Dedicated to protecting Harry (via Dumbledore's orders).
Fake Moody / Crouch Jr. (Bad):
- Death Eater; manipulates Harry into Triwizard Tournament.
- Uses "Constant Vigilance" teaching as cover for grooming Harry for Voldemort's return.
- Cruel, paranoid methods (Unforgivable Curses demo on students).
Verdict: The Moody we see is villainous; the real Moody is heroic but absent.