Arts >> Theater >> Drama

Holmes's Stick in "The Red-Headed League"

Correcting a Common Misremembering

In Arthur Conan Doyle's "The Adventure of the Red-Headed League," Sherlock Holmes does not thump his stick on the pavement in front of the pawnbroker's shop. The action occurs inside Jabez Wilson's office.

The Actual Scene

  1. Holmes and Watson visit Wilson's pawnshop/office.
  2. Holmes examines the floor, noting unusual wear in front of the safe.
  3. He uses his cane to tap and measure the floorboards, detecting a hollow resonance.
  4. He then strikes the floor rhythmically to confirm a hidden cellar/tunnel beneath.
  5. This reveals the criminals' tunnel from the adjacent building to the bank vault.

Significance

The pavement-thumping is a common misremembering, likely conflated with other Holmes adaptations where he taps surfaces outdoors.

Drama

Related Categories