* The "Mean Girl" Persona: Brooke had always been portrayed as the popular, wealthy, and sometimes self-absorbed girl. While this was initially endearing, it began to wear thin for some viewers as the show progressed. Her choices and actions were often seen as selfish and she often put her own needs above others. This was amplified in Season 6, making her seem particularly unsympathetic.
* Unhealthy Relationships: Brooke's romantic relationships in Season 6 were particularly messy and dysfunctional. Her on-again, off-again relationship with Julian was marked by jealousy, possessiveness, and a lack of communication. Her brief relationship with Chase was also tumultuous, highlighting her tendency to seek validation through romantic relationships.
* The "Not So Nice" Side: Brooke's previously strong, independent image was challenged in Season 6. She was shown struggling with self-doubt, vulnerability, and a desperate need for approval. This made her appear more flawed and less likeable to viewers.
* The "It's All About Me" Attitude: While Brooke was trying to navigate her own personal issues, her actions often came across as selfish and self-centered. She struggled to prioritize her friends and often put her own desires above their needs. This lack of empathy led to friction with many of her relationships.
* The "Over-the-Top" Drama: The show's writers leaned into the "dramatic" aspects of Brooke's character, often pushing her into extreme situations. This contributed to the feeling that she was being portrayed as overly emotional and unstable.
It's important to note that not all viewers felt the same way about Brooke in Season 6. Some fans appreciated the vulnerability and complexity the writers were trying to explore. However, overall, there was a significant amount of criticism leveled at the character and her storylines during this season.