No. Eddie Cibrian guest-starred in Season 4, Episode 25: "The Fisher King (Part 2)" as Sean Ellis—a suspect, not a serial killer.
The BAU investigates a serial killer (The Fisher King); Ellis is a person of interest. Cibrian did not play the unsub (William Hightower / actual Fisher King).
Possible confusion: He played a killer in another show (Third Watch, CSI: Miami) or you're mixing actors.