Jason Gideon (Mandy Patinkin) resigned from the BAU at the end of Season 2 (episode "The Fisher King, Part II").
After being captured and tortured by a serial killer, he suffered severe PTSD and realized he could no longer do the job. He appears later in brief guest spots (Season 5's "The Fisher King," Season 8's "The Replicator") but never returns as a series regular. Patinkin's departure was abrupt and reportedly due to creative differences and the show's graphic content, making Gideon's exit one of the most notable in the series' history.