Connections Between 'Charles' and 'Miss Awful': Structural Isomorphism in Two Stories
Shirley Jackson's "Charles" (1948) and Arthur Cavanagh's "Miss Awful" (1970s?) share striking parallels:
- First-person unnamed narrator closely observing a disruptive child.
- Child's invented persona: "Charles" (kindergarten bad boy) / "Miss Awful" (strict substitute teacher).
- Twist ending: Charles = narrator's own son (Laurie); Miss Awful = narrator's imagination/projection?
- Themes: Perception vs. reality; childhood/adult authority; narrative unreliability.
- Tone: Deadpan humor masking unease.
Critical Note: Some scholars suggest Cavanagh may have been inspired by Jackson (or vice versa if dates allow), or both draw on a folkloric "trickster child" archetype. They are not the same story—different authors, publications, details—but structurally isomorphic.