"Pyramus and Thisbe" in A Midsummer Night's Dream: When Bad Theatre Reveals Good Theatre
The mechanicals' performance of "The Most Lamentable Comedy and Most Cruel Death of Pyramus and Thisbe" in Act V, Scene 1 of A Midsummer Night's Dream is Shakespeare's most sustained meta-theatrical joke—a play-within-a-play that parodies amateur theatre while secretly mirroring the main plot's themes.
The Source Myth
The story comes from Ovid's Metamorphoses (IV.55–166): Babylonian lovers separated by a wall, communicating through a crack, meeting at a mulberry tree, and dying by double suicide. Shakespeare's audience knew the tale well, which makes the mechanicals' butchery of it all the funnier.
The Cast of "Rude Mechanicals"
- Bottom (weaver) → Pyramus
- Flute (bellows-mender) → Thisbe
- Snout (tinker) → Wall
- Snug (joiner) → Lion
- Starveling (tailor) → Moonshine
- Quince (carpenter) → Prologue
The Comedy of Incompetence
- Prologue: Quince recites punctuation marks as words—"period," "comma."
- Wall: Snout holds up his fingers to make a literal "hole" for the lovers to speak through.
- Lion: Snug roars gently, then breaks character to explain he is not a real lion.
- Moonshine: Starveling enters carrying a lantern, a bush, and a dog.
- Deaths: Bottom dies with elaborate melodrama; Flute stabs herself with a "sword" that is clearly a pipe.
- Mulberry: The "blood" that turns the berries purple is explained by Quince rather than shown.
Dramatic Functions: More Than Parody
- Parody: Mocks bad acting, amateur theatre conventions, and tragic excess.
- Mirror: Echoes the main plot—forbidden love, miscommunication, death.
- Contrast: The lovers' sincere passion versus the mechanicals' sincere incompetence.
- Class commentary: Artisans aspiring to aristocratic art forms.
- Meta-theatre: The play comments on playmaking itself.
Onstage Audience Reactions
Theseus: "This very palpable gross play / Well shadowed the substantial blot." Hippolyta: "This is the silliest stuff that ever I heard." The lovers mock mercilessly. Their reactions model the sophisticated viewer's response—even as the mechanicals' earnestness wins a strange affection.
Bad theatre, Shakespeare suggests, can illuminate the craft of good theatre by showing what happens when every convention is misunderstood.