Arts >> Theater >> Comedy

The Outsiders: Ponyboy & Johnny's Options After the Killing (And What They Chose)

The Situation

After Johnny kills Bob Sheldon in self-defense, the two boys—14 and 16—face a manhunt. Dally Winston gives them a gun, money, and four options:

  1. Windrixville (Jay Mountain Church) – Temporary hideout in an abandoned church. Safe but isolated; police search expands daily.
  2. Freight Train – High risk: railroad bulls, exposure, no supplies, illegal riding.
  3. Texas / Mexico – Dally's preferred long-term plan. Requires money, transport, evading a multi-state manhunt.
  4. Turn Themselves In – Legal consequences, but moral clarity. Johnny eventually wants this.

What They Actually Did

Option 1: The Church. They hide there for a week. Then—crucially—they leave to save children from a fire in the church. Johnny is critically injured. He dies days later. Dally, shattered, robs a store, threatens police with an unloaded gun, and dies by suicide-by-cop. Ponyboy faces court but is acquitted (self-defense).

The Irony

The flight delayed but didn't avoid the reckoning. The fire rescue—born from hiding—killed Johnny and Dally. Had they turned themselves in immediately (Option 4), the legal outcome might have been similar (juvenile court, self-defense), but the tragic cascade wouldn't have occurred. Hinton's point: running from consequences creates new, worse consequences.

Comedy

Related Categories