Arts >> Theater >> Comedy

The Blackboard Puzzle in *Charly* (1968): "That That Is..."

One of cinema's most memorable linguistic moments occurs in Charly (1968), when Cliff Robertson's intellectually disabled protagonist, Charly Gordon, writes a seemingly nonsensical run-on sentence on a blackboard and challenges his class to punctuate it.

The Sentence

"That that is is that that is not is not is that it it is."

The Solution

"That that is, is. That that is not, is not. Is that it? It is."

Decoding the Meaning

Parsed correctly, the sentence reveals a profound philosophical statement:

"What exists, exists. What does not exist, does not. Is that the truth? It is."

Why This Scene Matters

The puzzle demonstrates Charly's peak intellectual awakening after experimental surgery boosts his IQ. In this moment, he grasps logic, ontology, and the structure of language itself. The scene is a triumph—briefly—before his tragic regression begins. It encapsulates the film's central themes: the nature of intelligence, the fragility of human achievement, and the thin line between brilliance and loss.

Robertson's Oscar-winning performance makes the scene unforgettable, turning a grammar exercise into a meditation on existence.

Comedy

Related Categories