Jimmy Valentine: The Safecracker Who Found Redemption in O. Henry's Classic
There is no short story titled "Who Killed Jimmy Valentine?" The title you're likely thinking of is **A Retrieved Reformation** by **O. Henry** (William Sydney Porter), first published in 1903. Its protagonist is **Jimmy Valentine**, a notorious professional safecracker.
The Arc of Jimmy Valentine
- The Pro: He's the best in the business—cool, precise, uncatchable. He serves a prison stint but returns to his trade immediately upon release.
- The Turn: He arrives in Elmore, Arkansas, intending to case a bank. He meets Annabel Adams, the banker's daughter. Love strikes. He decides to go straight, adopting the identity of "Ralph D. Spencer," a shoe salesman. He builds a life, a reputation, an engagement.
- The Test: A child locks herself in the new bank's vault. No one else can open it in time. Jimmy faces the ultimate choice: reveal his past and skills to save the child, losing Annabel and his new life, or walk away and let the child die.
- The Reformation: He opens the vault. Ben Price, the detective who's tracked him for years, witnesses it. But Price chooses mercy—he pretends not to recognize "Ralph," letting Jimmy keep his redemption.
It's a masterclass in the "honorable thief" trope. Jimmy Valentine is the story. The title A Retrieved Reformation refers entirely to his moral rescue.