The story is "The Face of the Clock" (not "On the Face of It"), a short story by Susan Hill.
An unnamed narrator recalls his frail childhood friend Joseph, who dies mysteriously. Years later, the narrator encounters a man with Joseph's uncanny resemblance, triggering a psychological haunting that blurs memory, guilt, and the supernatural. The "clock face" motif marks the moment of Joseph's death and the narrator's repressed complicity.
Hill's signature: atmospheric, slow-burn dread, precise sensory detail (ticking clocks, cold rooms, faded wallpaper). More psychological than jump-scare horror.