Early Seasons:
* Initial Blindness: Emily initially believed Jenna was a victim of the same stalker terrorizing the girls, but this belief was based on deception by Jenna and her accomplice, Toby.
* Unintentional Harm: In a misguided effort to help Jenna, Emily, along with the other girls, unknowingly orchestrated a plan that led to Jenna's "accidental" blindness. This was a major turning point in their relationship and fueled a deep resentment in Jenna.
* Guilt and Regret: Emily felt immense guilt over Jenna's blindness and later attempted to make amends by helping her navigate her new reality. However, Jenna remained unforgiving.
Later Seasons:
* Jenna's Manipulation: Jenna used her "victim" status to manipulate and threaten the girls, particularly Emily. She leveraged their guilt and fueled their fear with calculated moves.
* The "A" Connection: Jenna's connection to "A" was revealed, making her an antagonist and fueling a sense of mistrust between her and Emily.
* A Shift in Perspective: As the series progressed, Emily began to understand Jenna's motivations and the trauma she endured, leading to a more empathetic perspective. She also saw Jenna's vulnerability and manipulation, recognizing the complexities of her character.
Overall:
Emily's actions towards Jenna were driven by a combination of naivety, guilt, and a desire to help. While she caused unintentional harm, she also attempted to make amends and ultimately learned to see Jenna as a complex character with a complicated past. Their relationship remained fraught with tension and distrust, but it wasn't solely defined by negativity.
It's important to note that the relationship between Emily and Jenna is a recurring theme throughout the series, and its nuances are explored in detail.