"Nancy (With the Laughing Face)": Not a Sinatra Composition
Contrary to common assumption, Frank Sinatra did not write "Nancy (With the Laughing Face)." The song was composed by:
- Music: Jimmy Van Heusen (Edward Chester Babcock) – Sinatra's longtime collaborator ("All the Way," "High Hopes," "Love and Marriage").
- Lyrics: John Myer (pen name for Johnny Burke?) – Actually, Phil Silvers claimed lyric credit in some sources; the official ASCAP registration lists Jimmy Van Heusen (music) and Johnny Burke (lyrics). *Correction: The lyricist is **Johnny Burke** (not John Myer—likely a transcription error in the source). Burke wrote "Pennies from Heaven," "Swinging on a Star," "Misty" (lyrics).
Origin Story
The song was written for Nancy Sinatra's birthday (Frank's daughter, born 1940). Van Heusen and Burke crafted it as a personal gift; Frank recorded it in 1944 (Columbia). It became a signature tune—he sang it to her at family gatherings for decades.
Notable Recordings
- Frank Sinatra (1944, 1963 Sinatra's Sinatra)
- Nat King Cole, Rosemary Clooney, Jimmy Durante, Michael Bublé, Seth MacFarlane
Sinatra was the definitive interpreter, not the author. The confusion persists because the song feels so intimately *his*.